Raspberry Pi and the rise of small computers

=Raspberry Pi Model A The Raspberry Pi is just one of many tiny computers now available

Related Stories

If small is beautiful, then in recent months the computer world has been burgeoning with beauty thanks to the growing number of teeny, tiny machines being released.

The Raspberry Pi has led this pack, purely because more than a million of them have been sold since orders started being accepted on 29 February 2012. Also available at this lower end of the market are devices from VIA, Rikomagic, Mele, Texas Instruments and Hiapad.

The loveliness does not stop there, as many others, such as FXI, Xi3, Zotac and even Intel, are producing dinky devices. Intel's contender, called the NUC or Next Unit of Computing, is about the size of a box of 80 teabags.

These small devices had emerged because of "massive changes" in the way people used computers, said Ranjit Atwal, research director at market analysis firm Gartner.

NUC Intel says its NUC is suited to being a media hub or to power interactive kiosks

It used to be the case that people bought one computer to do everything, said Mr Atwal.

"Now," he said, "you buy the device to match your particular need."

In the same way that people buy a smartphone to browse on the move, if they want to try their hand at coding, they opt for the Raspberry Pi or one of its rivals.

Similarly, if they want a home media server for their DVDs, they pick Intel's NUC or perhaps something from Zotac or Xi3.

The prices of these small form factor machines varies widely but all these gadgets can, with a little help from a few add-ons and peripherals, do anything that used to require the services of a fully functioning, and quite hefty, desktop PC.

Developing demand

Two things stand out for us in terms of our experience with the developing world over the past year.

The first is the role of South Africa as a beachhead into the rest of sub-Saharan Africa.

If you look at a map of where Pis are selling, you can see a hotspot there, and many of the people we talk to are buying with a view to marketing them to the emerging urban middle class to the north.

A less positive experience has been the impact of state-monopoly postal services and punitive tariffs - often as high as 100% - on availability in markets such as Brazil.

There, a $35 (£23) Pi will currently cost you the best part of $100 (£66).

I believe that these measures, aimed at fostering local manufacturing, risk holding back the emergence of a modern knowledge economy in these countries.

Mr Upton and his colleague Pete Lomas were responsible for designing the arrangement of the Raspberry Pi's hardware and its system-on-chip software.

"There are a lot of tiny PCs out there in the market place," said Intel spokesman John Deatherage. "There's a growing spectrum of people needing computer power in a small form factor."

There were two main reasons for the emergence of small PCs, he said. One aesthetic and one technical.

The aesthetic reason was that computers had begun emerging from spare rooms and box-rooms and were taking up residence in living rooms. In some of those cases, people did not want a "beige box" squatting on their carpet, he said. Far better to have something small and unobtrusive.

Those machines being used in front rooms and other places were not "replacements" for the family PC but "were going where the need was felt", he said.

The technical trend is linked to the driving force of the computer world: Moore's Law.

Coined by Intel co-founder Gordon Moore, this economic law states that the number of transistors that can be placed on a chip for the same cost will double roughly every two years. More transistors in a smaller space typically translates to more power.

Chip development, memory density and a host of other technological innovations meant that now small did not mean puny, said Mr Deatherage.

Colossus computer The first computers had to be very big
Power game

This, said James Gorbold, former editor of Custom PC, stood in sharp contrast to the situation barely a decade ago that emphasised size and brute force.

Problems with Pi

I ordered the Raspberry Pi when it first launched and had to wait five months for it to arrive.

I was so excited when it eventually came in the post, but it was just a box with the Pi in it and a thing telling me to put it onto something rubber to prevent electrical damage.

It was a big anti climax for me - there were no real instructions in there to tell you what to do.

You have to know to type "Start X" when you first turn the Pi on, but you only know that if you figure out you have to download the manual off the website first.

I ended up buying paper versions of both the official user manual and a beginner's guide to Python, which cost about the same as the Pi itself.

I bought it to learn to code, but I haven't really used it enough times because I need to keep referring to the books.

It's really good for teaching kids and I would recommend it, but it definitely needs to come with more instructions.

"Five to 10 years ago there was a trend towards really big machines," he said. "Hulking great gaming PCs filled with multi-coloured lights that needed water cooling."

"Now," he said, "the market has matured. People want something a bit more stylish and discrete."

It's matured thanks to the growing move to portable computing, which emphasised low power components, he said.

Less power going in means less heat coming out and removes the need for fans and other devices to cool the hot chips and other components doing all the hard work.

Many of the components found in small form factor PCs were more commonly found in phones, tablets or laptops, said Mr Gorbold.

For instance, the chip at the heart of the Raspberry Pi is more usually found in a handset. Similarly, hard drives and other components used in small machines from Dell, Apple and many others were initially developed for use in laptops.

Intel, in particular, said Mr Gorbold, had worked hard to reduce power consumption across all its processors for years, making it possible to put them in little boxes that do not need cooling.

For Mr Atwal, from Gartner, the shift to smaller PCs was also an indicator of the reality of the broader PC market.

"Over the last 10 years, who has made money in the PC world?" he asked. "It's Microsoft and Intel."

IBM PC IBM's early PCs established the look of the desktop "beige box"

By contrast PC makers, he said, were operating on razor-thin margins and struggled to prosper, let alone think about new products.

"This means their ability to innovate is more and more limited," he said.

Increasingly, PC box shifters relied on Intel and other component makers to do the innovation for them. This reduced their risk and left them less exposed should they back a trend that did not catch on with consumers.

This, Mr Atwal said, helped to explain the current wave of "experimentation" in the PC market that had led to the emergence of lots of different types of small machines.

"It's one thing doing the innovation and its another entirely to position and market the final product," he said.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Technology stories


Features & Analysis

BBC Future

Sketch of concept of new bus stops

Public transport gets personal

Radical rethink makes bus systems smart


  • A scene from BlancanievesTalking Movies

    Tom Brook looks at Blancanieves - a silent, black and white interpretation of Snow White

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.